{ "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "status": "completed", "createdAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.412Z", "updatedAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.458Z", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "currentDir": "/workspace", "model": "fixture-model", "modelProvider": "openai-compatible-gateway", "modelAuthSource": "api-key", "artifactRoot": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture", "policyEvents": [ { "type": "cf-harness.policy-event", "severity": "denied", "mode": "enforce-explicit", "toolId": "bash", "toolCallId": "call-unattested", "detail": "bash output did not include trusted CFC mediation metadata", "observationDenied": { "type": "cf-harness.observation-denied", "reason": "not-observable", "detail": "bash output did not include trusted CFC mediation metadata", "handle": { "type": "cf-harness.opaque-handle", "handleId": "cfc-audit-fixture:bash:2:output", "scope": "run", "createdAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.433Z" } }, "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.433Z" } ], "toolOutputs": [ { "type": "cf-harness.tool-result-ref", "outputId": "cfc-audit-fixture:bash:1", "toolId": "bash", "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "artifactPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture/tool-outputs/cfc-audit-fixture_bash_1-bash.json" }, { "type": "cf-harness.tool-result-ref", "outputId": "cfc-audit-fixture:bash:2", "toolId": "bash", "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "artifactPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture/tool-outputs/cfc-audit-fixture_bash_2-bash.json" }, { "type": "cf-harness.tool-result-ref", "outputId": "cfc-audit-fixture:delegate_task:3", "toolId": "delegate_task", "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "artifactPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture/tool-outputs/cfc-audit-fixture_delegate_task_3-delegate_task.json" } ], "failureRecords": [ { "type": "cf-harness.failure-record", "kind": "tool_not_allowed", "source": "policy_event", "detail": "bash output did not include trusted CFC mediation metadata", "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.433Z", "toolId": "bash", "toolCallId": "call-unattested" } ], "handleTable": { "type": "cf-harness.handle-table", "version": 1, "salt": "cfc-audit-fixture", "entries": [ { "token": "cfh:a:jvhdg", "kind": "address", "ref": "/of:fid1:AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA", "addressKey": "[null,\"of:fid1:AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA\",\"space\",[]]" } ] }, "capabilitySnapshot": { "type": "cf-harness.capability-snapshot", "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.416Z", "commands": { "bash": { "present": true, "path": "/bin/bash", "version": "GNU bash, version 5.2.26(1)-release" }, "sh": { "present": true, "path": "/bin/sh", "version": "BusyBox v1.36.1" }, "node": { "present": false }, "deno": { "present": true, "path": "/usr/local/bin/deno", "version": "deno 2.2.0" }, "python": { "present": false }, "python3": { "present": true, "path": "/usr/bin/python3", "version": "Python 3.11.9" }, "git": { "present": true, "path": "/usr/bin/git", "version": "git version 2.45.1" } }, "cfc": { "enforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "absenceBehavior": "permissive-if-absent", "substrateStatus": "not-attested", "runManifest": { "present": false }, "sandbox": { "kind": "docker-runsc-cfc", "defaultWorkingDirectory": "/workspace", "cfc": { "runtimeRequested": true, "workspaceMountPath": "/workspace" } }, "mounts": { "workspace": { "kind": "workspace", "status": "configured", "sandboxPath": "/workspace", "readOnly": false }, "fabric": { "kind": "fabric-fuse", "status": "not-configured", "sandboxPath": "/fabric", "writeGovernance": { "policy": "not-configured", "statusProbe": "not-probed", "delegatedToCfc": false } }, "hostBinds": [] }, "protectedXattrs": { "expectedSandboxVisible": false, "sandboxVisibility": "not-probed" } }, "model": { "providerId": "openai-compatible-gateway", "authSource": "api-key" } }, "capabilitiesPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture/capabilities.json", "promptSlotBinding": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "cfcPolicySnapshot": { "type": "cf-harness.cfc-policy-snapshot", "version": 1, "generatedAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.417Z", "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "cfc": { "enforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "enforcementModeSource": "explicit-config", "absenceBehavior": "permissive-if-absent", "substrateStatus": "not-attested" }, "runManifest": { "present": false }, "promptSlot": { "present": true, "bindingSource": "run-options", "binding": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" } }, "parentTools": { "allowance": "all-builtins", "allowedToolIds": [ "bash", "read_file", "view_image", "edit_file", "write_file", "delegate_task", "describe_handle" ] }, "skillScripts": { "allowedScripts": [] }, "subagents": { "allowedProfiles": [ "default" ], "profileConfigs": [ { "type": "cf-harness.subagent-profile-config", "profile": "default", "allowedToolIds": [ "bash", "read_file", "view_image", "edit_file", "write_file" ], "hostToolIds": [], "maxModelTurns": 8, "returnPolicy": { "type": "cf-harness.subagent-return-policy", "channel": "summary-and-sanitized-state", "includeSummary": true, "includeSanitizedRunState": true, "includeManifest": true, "includeTranscript": false, "includeRawFailureRecords": false } } ] }, "substrate": { "sandbox": { "kind": "docker-runsc-cfc", "defaultWorkingDirectory": "/workspace", "cfc": { "runtimeRequested": true, "workspaceMountPath": "/workspace" } }, "protectedXattrs": { "expectedSandboxVisible": false, "sandboxVisibility": "not-probed" } } }, "cfcPolicySnapshotPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture/policy-snapshot.json", "transcriptPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture/transcript.json", "policyDecisions": [ { "type": "cf-harness.policy-decision", "sequence": 1, "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.424Z", "toolActivitySequence": 1, "toolCallId": "call-attested", "toolId": "bash", "effectClass": "side-effect", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "decision": "allowed", "reasonCodes": [ "cfc_enforce_explicit_direct_command" ], "promptSlot": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "toolInputSummary": { "type": "cf-harness.tool-input-summary", "toolId": "bash", "commandBytes": 13, "commandDigest": "sha256:456712dcc4e823ef9d051b4ee84eb4d426b37afaadbd7ef67ee3234eee14f81f" } }, { "type": "cf-harness.policy-decision", "sequence": 2, "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.431Z", "toolActivitySequence": 2, "toolCallId": "call-unattested", "toolId": "bash", "effectClass": "side-effect", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "decision": "allowed", "reasonCodes": [ "cfc_enforce_explicit_direct_command" ], "promptSlot": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "toolInputSummary": { "type": "cf-harness.tool-input-summary", "toolId": "bash", "commandBytes": 57, "commandDigest": "sha256:b184a542fb834503a7d13bef200b5d39f796dd326019c7aec73b853a2e021acb" } }, { "type": "cf-harness.policy-decision", "sequence": 3, "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.436Z", "toolActivitySequence": 3, "toolCallId": "call-delegate", "toolId": "delegate_task", "effectClass": "side-effect", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "decision": "allowed", "reasonCodes": [ "cfc_enforce_explicit_direct_command", "subagent_profile_allowed" ], "promptSlot": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "toolInputSummary": { "type": "cf-harness.tool-input-summary", "toolId": "delegate_task", "profile": "default", "goalBytes": 39, "goalDigest": "sha256:34598b1728f61c0ec1dcc9c5d59f3f261f646d5e68375342b1bcd5120b49df96" }, "subagentProfile": "default" } ], "cfcInvocationContexts": [ { "type": "cf-harness.cfc-invocation-context", "version": 1, "sequence": 1, "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "createdAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.425Z", "toolId": "bash", "toolOutputId": "cfc-audit-fixture:bash:1", "operation": "shell", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "cwd": "/workspace", "promptSlot": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "runManifest": { "present": false }, "inputs": { "command": { "type": "cf-harness.redacted-text-summary", "bytes": 225, "digest": "sha256:81d67bfb17bb4bd2092eebb5146692adde9ff45271999b157023d8d17cd444d8" } }, "cfcInputLabels": { "version": 1, "entries": [ { "path": [ "command" ], "label": { "confidentiality": [ { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotInfluence", "version": 1, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" } ] } } ] } }, { "type": "cf-harness.cfc-invocation-context", "version": 1, "sequence": 2, "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "createdAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.431Z", "toolId": "bash", "toolOutputId": "cfc-audit-fixture:bash:2", "operation": "shell", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "cwd": "/workspace", "promptSlot": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "runManifest": { "present": false }, "inputs": { "command": { "type": "cf-harness.redacted-text-summary", "bytes": 269, "digest": "sha256:7a54dc3ecc17c77c4e89b46dccf58de419293a4376b86e00df014abd5d60c323" } }, "cfcInputLabels": { "version": 1, "entries": [ { "path": [ "command" ], "label": { "confidentiality": [ { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotInfluence", "version": 1, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "fixture-source" ] } } ] } } ], "cfcModelContext": { "type": "cf-harness.cfc-model-context", "version": 1, "updatedAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.429Z", "label": { "confidentiality": [ "fixture-source" ] }, "observations": [ { "type": "cf-harness.cfc-model-context-observation", "sequence": 1, "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.429Z", "toolCallId": "call-attested", "toolId": "bash", "outputId": "cfc-audit-fixture:bash:1", "channels": [ "stdout" ], "policy": "observed", "label": { "confidentiality": [ "fixture-source" ] } } ] }, "endedAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.456Z", "terminalReason": "assistant_completed", "primaryFailure": { "type": "cf-harness.failure-record", "kind": "tool_not_allowed", "source": "policy_event", "detail": "bash output did not include trusted CFC mediation metadata", "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.433Z", "toolId": "bash", "toolCallId": "call-unattested" }, "subagentRuns": [ { "type": "cf-harness.subagent-run-ref", "parentToolCallId": "call-delegate", "outputId": "cfc-audit-fixture:delegate_task:3", "childRunId": "cfc-audit-fixture.subagent.1", "status": "completed", "summary": "The child summarized the notes.", "manifest": { "type": "cf-harness.subagent-run-manifest", "version": 1, "parentRunId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "parentToolCallId": "call-delegate", "childRunId": "cfc-audit-fixture.subagent.1", "profile": "default", "depth": 1, "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "modelProvider": "openai-compatible-gateway", "modelAuthSource": "api-key", "model": "fixture-model", "modelSource": "parent", "allowedToolIds": [ "bash", "read_file", "view_image", "edit_file", "write_file" ], "hostToolIds": [], "maxModelTurns": 8, "confidentialityCeiling": { "source": "parent", "mode": "owner-view" }, "returnPolicy": { "type": "cf-harness.subagent-return-policy", "channel": "summary-and-sanitized-state", "includeSummary": true, "includeSanitizedRunState": true, "includeManifest": true, "includeTranscript": false, "includeRawFailureRecords": false }, "createdAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.437Z", "inputSummary": { "type": "cf-harness.subagent-input-summary", "goalBytes": 39, "goalDigest": "sha256:34598b1728f61c0ec1dcc9c5d59f3f261f646d5e68375342b1bcd5120b49df96" } }, "runState": { "status": "completed", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "createdAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.437Z", "updatedAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.450Z", "endedAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.442Z", "artifactRoot": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture.subagent.1", "transcriptPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture.subagent.1/transcript.json", "runReportPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture.subagent.1/run-report.json", "terminalReason": "assistant_completed", "policyEventCounts": { "total": 0, "warnings": 0, "denied": 0 }, "failureCount": 0 } } ], "policyTrace": { "type": "cf-harness.policy-trace", "version": 1, "generatedAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.456Z", "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "cfcPolicySnapshotPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture/policy-snapshot.json", "cfcPolicySnapshotDigest": "sha256:1ddc2ab8d7db3af265dfed9c537ac800cf0f98e33341c975f2971f5f85140a73", "decisionCounts": { "total": 3, "allowed": 3, "warned": 0, "denied": 0 }, "decisions": [ { "type": "cf-harness.policy-decision", "sequence": 1, "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.424Z", "toolActivitySequence": 1, "toolCallId": "call-attested", "toolId": "bash", "effectClass": "side-effect", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "decision": "allowed", "reasonCodes": [ "cfc_enforce_explicit_direct_command" ], "promptSlot": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "toolInputSummary": { "type": "cf-harness.tool-input-summary", "toolId": "bash", "commandBytes": 13, "commandDigest": "sha256:456712dcc4e823ef9d051b4ee84eb4d426b37afaadbd7ef67ee3234eee14f81f" } }, { "type": "cf-harness.policy-decision", "sequence": 2, "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.431Z", "toolActivitySequence": 2, "toolCallId": "call-unattested", "toolId": "bash", "effectClass": "side-effect", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "decision": "allowed", "reasonCodes": [ "cfc_enforce_explicit_direct_command" ], "promptSlot": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "toolInputSummary": { "type": "cf-harness.tool-input-summary", "toolId": "bash", "commandBytes": 57, "commandDigest": "sha256:b184a542fb834503a7d13bef200b5d39f796dd326019c7aec73b853a2e021acb" } }, { "type": "cf-harness.policy-decision", "sequence": 3, "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "at": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.436Z", "toolActivitySequence": 3, "toolCallId": "call-delegate", "toolId": "delegate_task", "effectClass": "side-effect", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "decision": "allowed", "reasonCodes": [ "cfc_enforce_explicit_direct_command", "subagent_profile_allowed" ], "promptSlot": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "toolInputSummary": { "type": "cf-harness.tool-input-summary", "toolId": "delegate_task", "profile": "default", "goalBytes": 39, "goalDigest": "sha256:34598b1728f61c0ec1dcc9c5d59f3f261f646d5e68375342b1bcd5120b49df96" }, "subagentProfile": "default" } ], "cfcInvocationContexts": [ { "type": "cf-harness.cfc-invocation-context", "version": 1, "sequence": 1, "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "createdAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.425Z", "toolId": "bash", "toolOutputId": "cfc-audit-fixture:bash:1", "operation": "shell", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "cwd": "/workspace", "promptSlot": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "runManifest": { "present": false }, "inputs": { "command": { "type": "cf-harness.redacted-text-summary", "bytes": 225, "digest": "sha256:81d67bfb17bb4bd2092eebb5146692adde9ff45271999b157023d8d17cd444d8" } }, "cfcInputLabels": { "version": 1, "entries": [ { "path": [ "command" ], "label": { "confidentiality": [ { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotInfluence", "version": 1, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" } ] } } ] } }, { "type": "cf-harness.cfc-invocation-context", "version": 1, "sequence": 2, "runId": "cfc-audit-fixture", "createdAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.431Z", "toolId": "bash", "toolOutputId": "cfc-audit-fixture:bash:2", "operation": "shell", "cfcEnforcementMode": "enforce-explicit", "cwd": "/workspace", "promptSlot": { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotBound", "source": { "type": "cf-harness.cli-input", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture" }, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "runManifest": { "present": false }, "inputs": { "command": { "type": "cf-harness.redacted-text-summary", "bytes": 269, "digest": "sha256:7a54dc3ecc17c77c4e89b46dccf58de419293a4376b86e00df014abd5d60c323" } }, "cfcInputLabels": { "version": 1, "entries": [ { "path": [ "command" ], "label": { "confidentiality": [ { "type": "https://commonfabric.org/cfc/atom/PromptSlotInfluence", "version": 1, "role": "direct-command", "kernelName": "cf-harness", "surface": "cfc-audit-fixture", "subject": "cfc-audit-fixture", "eventId": "cfc-audit-fixture-prompt" }, "fixture-source" ] } } ] } } ] }, "policyTracePath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture/policy-trace.json", "runReportPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture/run-report.json", "cellLabels": { "type": "cf-harness.cell-labels", "version": 1, "generatedAt": "2026-09-02T02:06:50.458Z", "status": "unavailable", "unavailableReason": "space-not-found", "unavailableDetail": "the fixture run has no fabric session, so no space database was opened", "cells": [] }, "cellLabelsPath": "/Users/ben/.bb/worktrees/env_7rq66gp6pp/labs/packages/cf-harness/audit/test/fixtures/runs/cfc-audit-fixture/cell-labels.json" }